Site Menu

June 10th, 2026 46 comments

We earn a commission for products purchased through some links in this article.

Where We Stand, Where We Fall The politics of Doctor Who

Available to order from www.amazon.co.uk or direct from www.hernebooks.com

Where We Stand, Where We Fall The politics of Doctor Who by Lizbeth Myles


‘A brilliant take on the history of Doctor Who’

~ Sophie Aldred, Ace in Doctor Who

‘The definitive work on the subject … I adored it’
~ Paul Cornell, writer of Doctor Who, Saucer County, and Witches of Lychford

‘Intelligent and thought-provoking’

~ Steven Moffat, head writer and executive producer of Doctor Who

This book demonstrates that cultural icon Doctor Who is, always has been, and always should be, a political narrative.

As this much-loved science- fiction show, now in its 63rd year, continues to entertain audiences around the world, some people have complained that the writing, themes and presentation are too political. But, claims Lizbeth Myles, Doctor Who has always explored important and controversial political issues, and it is vital that it continues to do so. This insightful, intelligent and entertaining book looks back at some of the most prominent political themes that the series has tackled over the decades – including Nuclear Annihilation, Feminism, Colonialism, Environmentalism, Scientific Responsibility, and Transhumanism – the historical context in which they have been framed, and how the messaging has changed in different eras of the show’s history.

PRAISE for Where We Stand, Where We Fall:

‘A brilliant take on the history of Doctor Who, this is no dry political essay. It’s an engaging, thoughtful, deeply researched and heartfelt look at our beloved programme which has always reflected and sometimes even prophesied the state of our universe.’
Sophie Aldred, Ace in Doctor Who

‘Where We Stand, Where We Fall is a very apt title for a book that clearly delineates, possibly for the first time, the six central debates of Doctor Who, the ideas the show keeps returning to. It’s wise, ambitious and funny, and clearly written with an enormous love for and knowledge of the series. It’s the platform upon which much future scholarship will be built, the definitive work on the subject, pulling together a vast number of threads. I adored it.’
Paul Cornell, writer of Doctor Who, Saucer County, and Witches of Lychford

‘Doctor Who has been many things over the years. This book offers an intelligent and thought-provoking look at one of the most debated aspects of it – its politics. Liz Myles knows her stuff.’

Steven Moffat, head writer and executive producer of Doctor Who (2010-2017)

ABOUT THE AUTHOR: Lizbeth Myles is an award-winning podcaster, writer, and editor. She’s a three-time Hugo award finalist: she was nominated twice for her work on the Verity! podcast, and once for editing the Doctor Who essay anthology Chicks Unravel Time. She’s written Doctor Who and Blake’s 7 for Big Finish and the BBC and contributed articles to SFX and Doctor Who Magazine. She lives in Kirkcudbrightshire, Scotland.


Categorised under: Books, Reference books

Adverts/Affiliates

46 comments

  • Missyrules

    June 20th, 2026 - 1:15pm

    Should say I’ve read this book, well half of it as I’ve just started it. My partner has no interest in politics but I do. Its well written and interesting but it is what it is. Don’t buy if you don’t like politics

    Reply
  • Bunter

    June 14th, 2026 - 11:34am

    Doctor Who isn’t cancelled, the placeholder Christmas special is cancelled. A chunk of ‘The Fans’ and a whole industry of hate-tubers are absolutely thrilled about this and, quite frankly, have never been as excited about the show as in the last two eras. People have been writing long, weepy, cherry-picking eulogies for the show since at least 2017. Some of the reaction to this book appears to be an extension of all this…

    Reply
    • beef

      June 14th, 2026 - 8:33pm

      Tell me about it. So many ice cold takes about “political messaging” like people haven’t been harping on about that for over half a century lol

  • War Chief.

    June 10th, 2026 - 5:18pm

    Exactly, Fh….stories like The Happiness Patrol and Vengeance on Varos being examples of the former…Just about all the stories after 2010 being examples of the latter….

    Reply
    • Missyrules

      June 10th, 2026 - 5:55pm

      Wouldn’t say the moffat era did that. Chibnall onwards yes, and I didn’t mind chibnall so much, it just became too much message not enough story in Davies return

    • War Chief.

      June 10th, 2026 - 6:01pm

      Peter Capaldi’s last season was a little….preachy…A great pity, as he had potential to be a really good Doctor.

    • Professor Litefoot

      June 10th, 2026 - 9:51pm

      I think most people didn’t notice how preachy Moffat was because he doesn’t write convincing human conversation. It’s all speeches and slogans and monologues and nicknames and undermining scenes with comedy quips. So even though post-2010 DW is absolutely stuffed full of Steven Moffat’s sociopolitical opinion, it’s difficult to take it seriously anyway because the primary function of the writing is to be cute.

    • War Chief.

      June 10th, 2026 - 10:02pm

      Thank you, Professor….that rather cheered me up…

    • beef

      June 11th, 2026 - 5:40pm

      Series 10 is the best one. I fw the doctor punching a racist.

    • War Chief.

      June 11th, 2026 - 6:10pm

      That’s my point, Beef….all the white men were nasty racists….it did get a bit repetitive….

    • beef

      June 12th, 2026 - 7:45am

      I think you’re misremembering because that’s not the case at all, also, a series featuring a black companion should tackle that subject matter for obvious reasons, not brush it under the rug like in that awful Shakespeare episode. I would also say that if repetition bugs you, there’s way more repetitive things throughout the show’s run, basically everything about it is repetitive lol

    • War Chief.

      June 12th, 2026 - 9:29am

      I’m afraid you’ve lost me, beef….Dr Who is the least repetitive show I know. Every few years there’s a complete change of cast and characters (even the main character…!) and the show would have a fresh, intriguing, new look to it…
      And what was wrong with the Shakespeare episode….? I rather liked it…

    • Peter

      June 19th, 2026 - 9:02am

      War Chief – certain runs are completely repetitive. S5 “base under siege”. S13/14 “gothic horror” stories (this week it’s the Dr Who version of: Frankenstein, Invasion of the Body Snatchers (twice!), Thing from Another World” etc. S8 – “it’sThe Master! Again! Every time!” S25: two back to back stories have the exact same plot, different monster.

      I’ve been watching S6 every Sunday since last September (original air date – ends this Sunday with ep 10 of War Games) and there’s at least three stories where spacecraft need to function by homing in on a radio beam, for example.

  • Fh

    June 10th, 2026 - 4:20pm

    ‘This book demonstrates that cultural icon Doctor Who is, always has been, and always should be, a political narrative.’ Ah yes, that’s exactly what Sydney Newman was thinking when he conceived the show…

    ‘now in its 63rd year, continues to entertain audiences around the world’ spoke a bit too soon on this one.

    The trouble with books like this (i mean, maybe I’m unfairly pre-judging it but I’d wager it’s accurate) is it’s written by people that, somehow, genuinely can’t see the difference between how the show used to tackle topics and how it’s done it the past few years, especially under Russell ‘The message is for the kids’ Davies.
    Doctor Who used to make you think, not tell you what to think.

    Reply
    • Professor Litefoot

      June 10th, 2026 - 9:57pm

      Perfectly put. Haven’t looked into the writer, but maybe she is actually on a sensible wavelength with all this stuff? The description screams “dissertation I wrote when I was 20” though.

    • Amypondfan

      June 10th, 2026 - 10:03pm

      She wrote a short story in the scientific secrets of doctor who book back in 20whenever

    • ChrisP

      June 10th, 2026 - 10:39pm

      The blurb does say
      “how the messaging has changed in different eras of the show’s history.”
      I interpreted that as meaning that the book covers how the treatment of the themes has changed over the years.

    • beef

      June 11th, 2026 - 5:41pm

      you must not have watched much of the Pertwee era

    • Duncan

      June 14th, 2026 - 1:29pm

      I watched the Pertwee era in real time and not once did myself or my other Who loving friends at primary school or even secondary, mention politics. When we talked about The Green Death we talked about the maggots. With Curse of Peladon we wouldnt have known what the EU was. I guess older kids than us maybe discussed the politics but for us 8-12 year olds it was all about the story, the aliens, Jo, UNIT and the Doctor.

    • Duncan

      June 14th, 2026 - 1:30pm

      Well said, fh !

    • War Chief.

      June 14th, 2026 - 2:00pm

      Well said Duncan…! Green Death was all about the giant maggots for me, Curse of Peladon I thoroughly enjoyed due to the monsters….no one at my school had any clue about the EU in the 70s, myself least of all….
      It was all about the monsters, and the Story…! No messages rammed down our throats….and the show was highly successful, and the better for it…

    • War Chief.

      June 14th, 2026 - 2:17pm

      There’s a whooshing sound as messages always fly over my head….Apparently Robert Holmes wanted his excellent The Two Doctors to favour vegetarianism…..but Shockeye’s mouth watering descriptions of all the meat dishes he wanted to try put me firmly as a life long meat eater….!
      I draw the line at rats, however…

    • Barney hall

      June 14th, 2026 - 5:12pm

      Exactly. The show used to be good story fiest message second (if therebahd to be one) and the stories were so strong thst if the message went over your head or was absent entirely then yous till had a great time. Huge swathes of the last two show runners and Moffat started to do it toward she end of his Tennor were message first story second if at all and sadly mostly it was not at all.

    • Amypondfan

      June 14th, 2026 - 5:57pm

      My daughter who is nine was totally confused by the ending of dot and bubble. She just didn’t understand why they wouldn’t accept his help. I have to say I thought the episode did not need a message beyond don’t become obsessed with social media! The ending was very confusing for kids

    • beef

      June 14th, 2026 - 8:31pm

      Maybe the fact that none of you were catching on to obvious political messaging in the 70s is a hint as to why it’s more overt in today’s productions.

    • War Chief.

      June 14th, 2026 - 8:38pm

      Except there isn’t any Dr Who any more….which implies that the last few writers did rather over-egg the pudding….

    • Amypondfan

      June 14th, 2026 - 9:04pm

      In the 70’s the messaging was subtle, sometimes, and backed up by good stories. Now the message is all there is.

    • rich

      June 16th, 2026 - 10:14pm

      The trouble with commenting on something you haven’t read is that you have to make something up to be annoyed about

    • War Chief.

      June 17th, 2026 - 10:48am

      We do seem to have strayed somewhat from the point, which was this poor woman’s book….We need to get back on our astral plane…I believe they take off from Heathrow Airport….

    • bookcollector

      June 17th, 2026 - 10:57am

      I thought they took off from Cromer…

      Look this book is about politics in doctor who. I have no interest in it. But that’s just me. I’m sure others will find it fascinating. But before anybody comments on the writing perhaps people should read it first then comment on the quality of the writing. She isn’t new to doctor who having written several short stories and audios since 2008.

    • bookcollector

      June 17th, 2026 - 11:12am

      Apologies for the obscure downtime reference…

    • War Chief.

      June 17th, 2026 - 12:09pm

      I still want to read Downtime….sometime….
      It’s on my bucket list….

    • bookcollector

      June 17th, 2026 - 12:36pm

      I enjoyed the novel back in 1995. I’ve read it several times since and always enjoyed it.

    • War Chief.

      June 17th, 2026 - 12:51pm

      I read Ghost Light and Battlefield….very good…
      The Time Crucible one, less so….then Lungbarrow, of course…

    • bookcollector

      June 17th, 2026 - 1:14pm

      I read the times crucible one twice it was fine but it was the start of the whole 90’s “the doctor can’t have had a real granddaughter because that would mean (mouth the word in horror) s e x! Instead they came up with she wasn’t really his granddaughter and timelords were weaved on looms. I was pleased when Russell mentioned susan in the Tennant era of 2006 as his granddaughter then of course he ruined it all by the time ncuti ended! Lungbarrow is a book I’ve only read once. It was interesting but I can’t say I thought it was great. Battlefield and ghost light are very good though.

    • War Chief.

      June 17th, 2026 - 2:08pm

      So that was the purpose or reason behind the loons…!
      I didn’t really understand what they were, despite reading Time’s Crucibke several times….it wasn’t until Lungbarrow that all became clearer….
      For instance, I thought, if Time Lords are now sterile…..so, is the Doctor a contemporary of Rassilon, Omega etc after all…? He must be, if there are no more children….
      There was no Internet back then to explain it all to me…

    • Amypondfan

      June 19th, 2026 - 3:58pm

      Actually I do have a question about reality war. If the time lords are sterile and have been always as seems to being indicated then how are there billions of children on gallifrey in day of the doctor?

    • Rory, the original you might say

      June 19th, 2026 - 4:08pm

      @Amypondfan, they could be Gallifreyans who aren’t Time Lords, like the ones in Invasion of Time.

    • Missyrules

      June 19th, 2026 - 7:03pm

      Bit silly though isn’t it? We had pregnant time lords in arc of infinity. We had billions of children on gallifrey. Smacks more of just bad writing than a well thought out plot detail.

    • Scotel

      June 19th, 2026 - 7:56pm

      “That genetic explosion. It… it didn’t kill us, but it roasted us and sterilised us. Extinction is taking a bit longer, that’s all.”

      So no it hasn’t “always been” it’s only been the case since the Thirteenth Doctor’s era in-universe.

    • Missyrules

      June 20th, 2026 - 1:09pm

      To be honest I just don’t like Russell’s writing. The idea that the doctor hadn’t had kids yet was just daft to me. A pointless plot in a story that just didn’t work. Like others on here I thought the whole poppy idea was completely utterly involving. I think it was war chief who said it, I just didn’t care about the fate of the child. Give us better stuff with the villains for longer instead of the whole of look I’ve defeated another undefeatable god easily in five minutes now let’s spend 30 mins running around dealing with something so dull and so melodramatic it bordered on farce.

    • Missyrules

      June 20th, 2026 - 1:11pm

      That’s meant to be uninvolving. Oh and I get some people will like reality war. They can but it’s just not my thing.

    • War Chief.

      June 20th, 2026 - 2:44pm

      There were children in Day of the Doctor, and every other Stephen Moffat story, as he was a father and boringly obsessed with writing all about fatherhood in all his Dr Who stories….
      Excuse me….pregnant Time Lords in Arc of Infinity…?

    • Missyrules

      June 20th, 2026 - 4:39pm

      Yes, in a background shot. Don’t ask where I can’t remember but there is a pregnant time lady.

    • War Chief.

      June 20th, 2026 - 4:48pm

      Goodness….At least it wasn’t Lady Flavia….! Yes I know, she’s in The Five Doctors….What did Paul Cornell write about her…? Drunk in charge of a Sash….

  • Moodbeam

    June 10th, 2026 - 4:07pm

    Where we stand, where we fall.

    An apt name for a book on a day such as this.

    Goodbye Doctor, it was an absolute joy.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get your own avatar.
By clicking submit you agree to our terms and conditions (below), we reserve the right to edit or delete inappropriate messages.

Comment rules

The Doctor Who site welcomes constuctive comments related to the news article in question. Links posted in comments may not be displayed. We reserve the right to delete or edit any post entirely at our discretion. If you leave unacceptable comments your IP address will be banned and reported

Click here to read full comments terms and conditions

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Twitter

Facebook